Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Can a non-attendee submit comments to sway voters in an email vote under Robert's Rules

Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


We had an in-person presentation, motion, and discussion, but ran out of time before a vote could be held. We also wanted to ensure all voices were heard, so a vote was subsequently conducted by email. Two members voiced dissent by email after the vote. One had been present at the meeting; the other holds a 0.5 FTE position and does not attend meetings but has strong feelings on the matter. Quorum was present at the meeting during the discussion portion, and there are 16 full voting members. Can a potentially non-voting member submit comments to sway voting members?

Navigating This Procedural Situation

This is a multi-layered situation. Here is a breakdown of the key issues.


First: The Core Problem — Email Voting

Under RONR, email voting is not valid unless your bylaws or special rules of order explicitly authorize it.

RONR §49 provides that action by vote of a board or other body taken outside of a meeting — by mail, telephone, fax, email, or similar means — is not valid unless the bylaws or applicable law specifically authorize it.

This applies equally to committees and membership bodies. This is your most critical issue to resolve first.


Second: Assessing Your Email Vote

Question Answer Implication
Do your bylaws authorize electronic voting? Determine this first If no → vote is invalid
Was quorum present at the meeting? Yes (confirmed) Meeting itself was valid
Was any vote taken at the meeting? No No formal action was recorded

Third: The 0.5 FTE Member's Status

This is key — voting rights depend on membership status, not attendance or FTE level.

Ask these questions:

  • Are they listed as a voting member in your bylaws or governing documents?
  • Does 0.5 FTE status explicitly exclude voting rights?
  • Were they listed among your 16 full voting members?

If they are not a voting member:

  • They have no vote
  • They may still submit comments to influence others — RONR does not prohibit non-members from providing input if the body chooses to receive it
  • However, the body is under no obligation to consider their input

If they are a voting member:

  • Their absence from the meeting does not forfeit their rights
  • They are entitled to vote by whatever method is properly authorized

Fourth: The Dissenting Emails

Regarding the two members who voiced dissent by email:

  • The member present at the meeting had the right and opportunity to speak during debate. Their post-meeting email carries no formal procedural weight, though it may inform future discussion.
  • The 0.5 FTE non-attendee similarly — their email is not a formal parliamentary action regardless of the strength of their feelings.

Feelings expressed outside a properly called meeting have no parliamentary effect.


The Recommended Path Forward

If email voting is NOT authorized by your bylaws:
  1. Declare the email vote null and void
  2. Call a properly noticed meeting
  3. Place the motion on the agenda with proper notice
  4. Allow full debate, including from any members who wish to speak
  5. Hold a properly conducted vote at the meeting
If email voting IS authorized:
  1. Review the specific rules your bylaws set for electronic voting
  2. Ensure all eligible voting members (clarify the 0.5 FTE member's status) received the ballot
  3. Determine whether the vote was conducted per those rules
  4. Record the results accordingly in the minutes

Regarding "Ensuring All Voices Are Heard"

This is a laudable goal, but it must work within proper procedure. Options include:

  • Extended debate period at a properly called meeting
  • Written comments submitted before the vote (if your rules allow)
  • Secret ballot to reduce emotional pressure (RONR §45)
  • A special meeting called specifically for this item with proper notice

Bottom Line

⚠️ The most important action right now is to check your bylaws for email or electronic voting authorization. Everything else flows from that answer.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions