Can a motion to accept a slate of officers substitute for a proper election
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
At our AGM, a full slate of officers was presented but no motion to approve the slate was made initially. Then a motion was made to "accept the directors on the slate," which was seconded and voted on. Is that a proper election?
Procedural Issue: Election by Motion vs. Proper Election Procedure
This situation raises some important parliamentary concerns. Let me break it down.
What Should Have Happened
Under Robert's Rules, elections are conducted by:
- Nominations (from a nominating committee, floor, or both)
- Voting — typically by ballot, voice vote, or other method
- Each office is voted on separately, unless the assembly votes to elect the entire slate by unanimous consent
Robert's Rules covers elections and the proper process for nominating and electing officers.
Problems With What Occurred
1. "Accepting" or "Approving" a Slate by Motion is Irregular
A motion to "accept the slate" is not the standard election procedure under Robert's Rules. It can be problematic because:
- It may deprive members of the right to vote for individuals separately
- It could prevent write-in or floor nominations from being considered
- The word "accept" is ambiguous — does it mean elected, or just approved for consideration?
2. Were Directors Properly Elected?
The key question is whether the intent was clearly to elect these individuals. If the assembly understood the motion as electing the directors, and it passed, the election may stand as valid — but it is irregular procedure.
What You Should Do Now
| Situation | Recommended Action |
|---|---|
| Meeting is still in session | Raise a Point of Order immediately |
| Meeting has ended | The officers likely hold their positions unless challenged |
| Bylaws specify election procedure | Check if this motion violated your bylaws — that's more critical than Robert's Rules |
Key Caveat
Your bylaws take precedence. If your bylaws specify a particular election method (e.g., ballot vote, separate votes per office), and that wasn't followed, the election could be invalid and subject to challenge.
Bottom Line
The election is procedurally irregular but likely valid if:
- ✅ The motion clearly intended to elect (not just acknowledge) the slate
- ✅ Members had opportunity to make floor nominations
- ✅ Your bylaws don't require a different specific method