Can a motion that violates Robert's Rules be dismissed or overturned
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
If a motion passes in violation of Robert's Rules, can that motion be dismissed or overturned?
Challenging a Motion That Violates Robert's Rules
Yes, there are several ways to address a motion that was improperly passed. The approach depends on when the violation is discovered.
At the Time of the Violation
Point of Order
- Any member may raise a Point of Order immediately when a rule is violated
- Must be raised promptly — before business has moved on
- The chair rules on the point; if overruled, the member may Appeal the decision
- If sustained, the motion is declared out of order and has no effect
After the Fact
1. Motion to Rescind
- Can be made at any future meeting
- Requires:
- 2/3 vote, OR
- Majority vote if previous notice was given, OR
- Majority of the entire membership
- This undoes the action taken
2. Point of Order + Appeal
- For continuing violations (rules of order, not procedural errors), a Point of Order may still be timely even after the vote
3. Void Actions
- Some violations are so fundamental that the action is void from the start — for example:
- Action taken without a quorum
- Action that violates the bylaws or corporate charter
- These have no time limit for challenge
Key Distinction
| Type of Violation | Effect |
|---|---|
| Procedural rule violation | Voidable if timely raised |
| Bylaws/fundamental rule violation | Void ab initio (from the beginning) |
Practical Recommendation
Act quickly. The sooner a Point of Order is raised, the more likely it is to be accepted. Delaying can result in the chair ruling it untimely.