Can a motion ruled out of order before being stated be postponed
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
In Robert's Rules of Order, where is the description of how to treat a motion ruled out of order before the chair states it, when the maker then requests to postpone it for future consideration?
The specific scenario — where a motion has been ruled out of order before being stated and the maker then requests to postpone it for future consideration — isn't addressed as a distinct procedure in Robert's Rules of Order. Here's why, and how it would be handled in practice.
Why This Situation Is Unusual
Robert's Rules draws a sharp line at the moment the chair states the question. Before that point, the motion is not formally before the assembly — it belongs, in a sense, to the maker. After that point, the assembly controls it.
If the chair rules a motion out of order before stating it, the motion never becomes pending business. There is nothing for the assembly to postpone, because there is no motion on the floor.
Practical Treatment
Since the motion was never placed before the assembly:
- No subsidiary motion (such as Postpone Definitely) can apply — subsidiary motions only attach to pending questions.
- The maker simply retains their idea and may bring it back as a new motion at a future meeting when it is in order.
- The chair may helpfully note why the motion was out of order and when or how it could properly be introduced.
If the Maker Asks About Future Consideration
The chair might respond by noting that the motion is not in order at this time, stating the reason, and advising the member when or under what circumstances the matter could properly be brought before the assembly.
No formal action by the assembly is required or appropriate. The maker simply takes note and reintroduces the motion when conditions allow.