Can a motion request a formal apology from a member under Robert's Rules
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Can a member use a motion to request an apology from another member who violated rules or behaved improperly?
Motion to Request an Apology
Requesting an apology from a member who has violated rules or behaved improperly can be handled through parliamentary procedure, though it's important to understand what tools are available and how they work.
The Appropriate Motion
There is no special motion dedicated solely to requesting an apology. Instead, you would use a main motion to accomplish this. The motion might be framed something like:
"I move that the assembly request a formal apology from the member for [briefly describing the conduct]."
This motion follows the standard path:
- A member makes the motion during the appropriate time for new business (or old business if previously introduced)
- Another member seconds it
- The chair opens debate — members may discuss the merits
- The assembly votes — a simple majority is required to adopt it
Important Considerations
-
An assembly can request an apology, but cannot compel one. The motion expresses the will of the group; it cannot force a member to comply.
-
If the conduct was a rules violation, a Point of Order should have been raised at the time of the violation. If it was not raised promptly, the right to challenge that specific procedural breach may have passed.
-
More serious disciplinary action — such as censure, suspension, or expulsion — requires specific procedures outlined in Robert's Rules under disciplinary proceedings, and your organization's bylaws may also govern this.
-
A motion to censure is a stronger formal expression of disapproval than a request for an apology, and may be more appropriate depending on the severity of the conduct.
Which Is Right for Your Situation?
| Situation | Appropriate Action |
|---|---|
| Minor breach, apology sufficient | Main motion requesting apology |
| Formal expression of disapproval | Motion to censure |
| Serious misconduct | Formal disciplinary proceedings per bylaws |
| Ongoing rule violation during meeting | Point of Order to the chair |
If your bylaws contain specific disciplinary procedures, those rules take precedence and should be followed carefully.