Can a motion fail for lack of a second under Robert's Rules
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
According to Robert's Rules of Order, can a motion for approval be made and then considered failing if it does not receive a second?
Motions Failing for Lack of Second
Direct Answer
Yes, but with an important nuance. Under Robert's Rules, a motion that receives no second simply does not come before the assembly — it doesn't technically "fail" in the parliamentary sense (which would require a vote), but the practical effect is that the motion dies and business moves on.
How It Actually Works
- A member makes a motion
- The chair asks: "Is there a second?"
- If no second is received, the chair declares:
"The motion is not before the assembly for lack of a second"
- The motion is dropped — no vote is taken, no record of failure is created
**Robert's Rules — A second merely indicates that at least one other member wants the motion considered. It does not mean the seconder supports the motion.
Important Caveats
| Situation | Rule |
|---|---|
| In committee | Seconds are not required |
| Small boards (under ~12 members) | Seconds are often dispensed with in practice |
| Minutes | An unseconded motion should NOT be recorded in the minutes |
| Any member can second | Even someone opposed to the motion |
Key Distinction
❌ A motion lacking a second did not fail — it was never considered ✅ A motion that was voted on and defeated did fail
This distinction matters if someone later tries to Reconsider the motion — you can only reconsider a motion that was actually voted upon.