Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Can a motion fail for lack of a second under Robert's Rules

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


According to Robert's Rules of Order, can a motion for approval be made and then considered failing if it does not receive a second?

Motions Failing for Lack of Second

Direct Answer

Yes, but with an important nuance. Under Robert's Rules, a motion that receives no second simply does not come before the assembly — it doesn't technically "fail" in the parliamentary sense (which would require a vote), but the practical effect is that the motion dies and business moves on.


How It Actually Works

  1. A member makes a motion
  2. The chair asks: "Is there a second?"
  3. If no second is received, the chair declares:

"The motion is not before the assembly for lack of a second"

  1. The motion is dropped — no vote is taken, no record of failure is created

**Robert's Rules — A second merely indicates that at least one other member wants the motion considered. It does not mean the seconder supports the motion.


Important Caveats

Situation Rule
In committee Seconds are not required
Small boards (under ~12 members) Seconds are often dispensed with in practice
Minutes An unseconded motion should NOT be recorded in the minutes
Any member can second Even someone opposed to the motion

Key Distinction

❌ A motion lacking a second did not fail — it was never considered ✅ A motion that was voted on and defeated did fail

This distinction matters if someone later tries to Reconsider the motion — you can only reconsider a motion that was actually voted upon.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions