Can a motion fail for lack of a second and should it appear in minutes
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
My motion failed because it did not receive a second. Should it still go into the minutes?
Motion That Failed for Lack of a Second
No — a motion that fails to receive a second should NOT be recorded in the minutes.
Why Not?
Under Robert's Rules, when a motion does not receive a second, it is simply not placed before the assembly — it never officially becomes business before the body. Since nothing was actually decided or acted upon, there is nothing to record.
Under Robert's Rules, when a motion that requires a second gets none, the chair may ask whether there is a second and, if none is offered, announce that the motion is not seconded; the motion never comes before the assembly.
What the Minutes Should Record
Minutes are a record of what the assembly DID — actions taken, votes, and decisions made. They are not a record of:
- Failed attempts to make motions
- Motions that lacked a second
- Discussion or debate
Practical Note
If the lack of a second was disputed or caused confusion during the meeting, the chair may briefly note what happened for clarity in the records — but strictly speaking, Robert's Rules does not require it, and standard practice is to simply omit it.
Bottom line: Leave it out of the minutes. The motion never officially came before the assembly, so it has no place in the official record.