Can a motion fail for lack of a second and can the same person make and second it
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Is a second needed for a motion? Can the same person both make and second a motion?
Seconding Motions in Robert's Rules
Is a Second Required?
Yes, in most cases — a second is required before the chair can state a motion and open it for debate. The purpose of a second is simply to confirm that at least two members want the matter considered, preventing the assembly from wasting time on something only one person cares about.
Can the Same Person Make AND Second a Motion?
No. The same person cannot both make and second a motion. The seconder must be a different member than the maker of the motion.
The logic: if you made the motion, you obviously support considering it. A second must come from someone else to show broader interest.
Important Practical Notes
- The seconder does not need to support the motion — they only indicate they want it discussed
- The seconder's name is generally not recorded in the minutes
- A second is typically not required in the following situations:
- Motions made in committees (any size)
- Nominations
- Points of Order
- Division of the Assembly
- Requests that require no action by the assembly
If No Second is Given
The chair simply asks: "Is there a second?" If none comes, the motion dies and business moves on — no vote needed.