Can a motion be ignored for lack of a second in a small board
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
I'm on a small board of only 5 members, and they won't hear my motion because no one seconded it. They also refuse to include my motion in the minutes.
Can a Motion Be Ignored for Lack of a Second in a Small Board?
Short answer
In a small board, motions do not need a second unless the board has adopted a rule requiring them. If your board has about a dozen members or fewer and follows Robert's Rules, the chair should not refuse to take up a motion just because no one seconded it.
The small-board rules
Robert's Rules relaxes several formalities for small boards (about a dozen members or fewer present). Among them:
- Motions need not be seconded.
- Members may speak without rising, and may speak more than once.
- The chair may take part in discussion and may vote on all questions.
- Informal discussion of a subject is allowed while no motion is pending.
These relaxed rules apply unless the board's own rules or the organization's bylaws say otherwise, so check whether your board has adopted a rule requiring seconds.
What you can do
At the meeting
If the chair says your motion died for lack of a second, say:
"Point of order. This is a small board, and motions do not require a second."
The chair must rule on the point of order. If you disagree with the ruling, you can appeal. An appeal needs a second, and the chair's ruling stands unless a majority votes against it (a tie sustains the chair).
Afterward
When the minutes are presented for approval, you can move to correct them if they don't accurately reflect what happened, including your motion and the chair's ruling on it.
Also worth knowing
Even in a large assembly, where seconds are normally required, a missing second doesn't invalidate a motion once the chair has stated it and the assembly has debated or voted on it. The second only shows that at least two members want the question considered.