Can a member not in good standing be elected to the board
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Can an association member who is not in good standing with the association be elected to the board?
Member Not in Good Standing — Eligibility for Board Election
This is a great question, and the answer depends on multiple layers of authority that must be checked in order.
1. Check Your Bylaws First (Most Important)
Robert's Rules defers to an organization's own governing documents on this matter. Your bylaws may:
- Explicitly define what "good standing" means
- Specify eligibility requirements for candidates/nominees
- Restrict voting rights or officeholding for members not in good standing
If your bylaws address this, those provisions govern.
2. What Robert's Rules Says by Default
Under Robert's Rules, any member in good standing is eligible for office unless the bylaws say otherwise. This implies that a member not in good standing may be ineligible, but Robert's Rules itself does not define "good standing" — your bylaws must do that.
3. Common Bylaw Definitions of "Good Standing"
Organizations typically define good standing to include:
- Dues paid current
- No pending disciplinary action
- Compliance with membership requirements
4. Practical Steps to Determine Eligibility
- Review your bylaws for eligibility requirements for directors/officers
- Check your bylaws for the definition of "good standing"
- Check any membership rules or standing rules that may apply
- If bylaws are silent, the assembly may decide the question by majority vote
Key Caveat
⚠️ If a member is elected while ineligible, that election may be subject to challenge. A Point of Order should be raised before or during the election to address the issue at the proper time.
Bottom line: Most associations intend that members not in good standing are ineligible, but this must be explicitly stated in your bylaws to be enforceable under Robert's Rules. Review your governing documents carefully.