Can a member move to not approve minutes under Robert's Rules
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
A member has noted an intention to make a motion to not approve the minutes from a previous meeting, but approval of the minutes is the first item on the agenda. Is this proper procedure?
Motion to Not Approve Minutes
This situation involves a common misunderstanding about the nature of approving minutes. Let me clarify the procedure.
How Minutes Approval Actually Works
Approving minutes is not a motion-based process — it is handled by the chair putting a question directly to the assembly. The standard procedure is:
- Chair asks: "Are there any corrections to the minutes?"
- Members offer corrections (if any)
- Chair declares: "The minutes stand approved as read/corrected" — without a formal vote unless someone objects
The Member's Options
Since the chair controls this process, a member wishing to challenge or prevent approval would need to:
| Action | How |
|---|---|
| Offer specific corrections | Simply state the corrections during step 1 above |
| Object to approval | Object so that a formal vote is required |
| Move to postpone approval | If more time/information is needed |
What the Member Cannot Do
A member cannot make a main motion "not to approve" the minutes while minutes approval is already pending before the assembly, as that would conflict with the pending matter.
Key Practical Advice
If the member has specific objections to the content of the minutes, the proper avenue is to propose corrections — not to block approval entirely.
If the minutes contain a disputed record of what occurred, the assembly decides by majority vote what the correct record should be.