Can a member make a motion to stop revoting on a repeatedly defeated bylaw amendment
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
A bylaw amendment has been voted down twice and then reintroduced. Can a general member make a motion not to vote on it again?
Preventing Repeated Introduction of a Defeated Motion
This is an excellent practical question. Here are the options available to a general member.
The Core Problem
Robert's Rules does provide protection against repeatedly bringing up defeated business. A motion that has been defeated cannot be renewed at the same session. However, it can be reintroduced at a later session.
Options Available to a Member
1. Point of Order (if reintroduced too soon)
If the bylaw amendment is being reintroduced within the same meeting session, a member can rise to a Point of Order and state that the motion has already been defeated and cannot be renewed at this session.
- No second required
- Chair rules on it immediately
2. Objection to Consideration (if caught early)
If the motion is reintroduced at a new session, a member can raise an Objection to Consideration before any debate begins.
- Must be raised immediately before any debate
- Requires a 2/3 vote against consideration to suppress it
- Not debatable
3. Motion to Postpone Indefinitely
Once the motion is on the floor, a member can move to Postpone Indefinitely, which effectively kills the motion for that session.
- Requires a second
- Debatable
- Simple majority vote
An Important Consideration About Bylaw Amendments
Bylaw amendments typically have advance notice requirements. If proper notice was not given before reintroduction, that itself is grounds for a Point of Order to rule the motion out of order.
Bottom Line
A member cannot simply "motion not to vote", but they have several legitimate procedural tools to prevent repeated consideration of defeated business. The best tool depends on when in the process the motion reappears.