Can a member block repeated reintroduction of a defeated bylaw amendment
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
A bylaw amendment has been voted down twice and then reintroduced. Can a general member make a motion to prevent it from being voted on again?
Preventing Repeated Introduction of a Defeated Motion
This is an excellent question that touches on an important procedural protection.
The Short Answer
Yes — a member can raise this procedurally, but the tool isn't exactly a "motion not to vote again." The proper mechanism depends on the situation.
The Core Rule: Renewal of Motions
Under **Robert's Rules, a motion that has been defeated cannot be renewed (reintroduced) during the same session. If the bylaw amendment was voted down twice and reintroduced in the same meeting, any member can:
Rise to a Point of Order that the motion is not in order, because it was already defeated in the same session.
The chair should sustain the point and rule the motion out of order.
If the Reintroduction Is at a Later Meeting
If the motion is being reintroduced at a subsequent meeting or session, it is generally permissible. However, a member could:
- Move to Postpone Indefinitely — This would kill the motion for that session (majority vote)
- Move to Refer to Committee — Delays action (majority vote)
- Move to Postpone Definitely — Delays to a specific future time (majority vote)
Special Protection for Bylaws
Because this involves a bylaws amendment, check whether the bylaws specify:
- A waiting period before a failed amendment can be reintroduced
- A higher vote threshold for reintroduction
- Previous notice requirements
Many organizations adopt special rules precisely to prevent repeated attempts to change bylaws.
Practical Recommendation
If the assembly is frustrated by repeated reintroduction, the most direct solution is to adopt a special rule of order establishing a waiting period (e.g., six months) before a defeated bylaw amendment can be reintroduced. This requires a two-thirds vote to adopt.