Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Can a member ask the chair a question during debate under Robert's Rules

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


If a motion includes a quoted cost and a member asks, "This is a lot of money, isn't this expensive?" — is this an appropriate question during debate? Does the chair have to answer?

Debate vs. Questions in Deliberative Assemblies

This is a great practical question that touches on how debate actually works under Robert's Rules.


The Short Answer

That "question" is actually debate — and the chair does not answer it.


Why This Is Debate, Not a Question

Under Robert's Rules, members do not direct questions to the chair during debate on a motion (with limited exceptions). When a member says "This is a lot of money, isn't this expensive?" they are:

  • Expressing an opinion about the merits of the motion
  • Seeking agreement from others in the room
  • Arguing against the motion

This is debate, regardless of whether it is phrased as a question. The rhetorical framing does not change its nature.

Robert's Rules — Debate is the proper mechanism for members to express views for or against a pending motion.


When Questions Are Legitimate

A member may legitimately ask a question through the chair in two situations:

Situation Process
Point of Information A member may request factual information relevant to the motion (e.g., "What is the current budget balance?")
Parliamentary Inquiry A member may ask the chair about procedure (e.g., "Is this motion amendable?")

Even then, the chair directs the question to whoever can answer it — the chair does not personally answer substantive factual questions unless they happen to know the answer.


What the Chair Should Do

If a member phrases debate as a question directed at the chair, the chair should:

  1. Recognize it as debate and allow it to proceed as such
  2. Not answer the rhetorical question
  3. If needed, gently remind the member to address remarks to the assembly, not to the chair

Key Principle

The chair remains impartial and does not engage in debate or argue the merits of motions.

The chair's job is to manage the process, not weigh in on whether a cost is too high.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions