Can a failed candidate for one office run for another office in the same election
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
If an executive board member whose term is expiring is nominated for Vice President but not elected, does the organization need to hold a separate election for that person to get on the ballot for their original board member position, which is also up for election this year? Our bylaws do not address this scenario.
Nomination and Election for Multiple Positions
This is a practical question that Robert's Rules addresses through general principles, since your bylaws don't cover this specific scenario.
The Short Answer
No, a separate nomination process is generally not required, but the organization needs to handle this carefully. Here's why and how:
The Core Principle
Under Robert's Rules, a person's nomination for one office does not automatically place them on the ballot for a different office. Each office has its own separate election. However, nominations can be made — and reopened — at the appropriate time in the meeting.
Recommended Procedural Approach
When you reach the election for the board member position:
- Open nominations for that position (if nominations weren't already closed for all positions simultaneously)
- The individual — or anyone else — may be nominated at that time for the board member seat
- The election proceeds normally
Key point: If your elections are conducted sequentially (Vice President first, then board members), nominations for the board seat should still be open when you reach that item, allowing the person to be placed on the ballot.
If Nominations Were Already Closed
If your process closed all nominations at once before any elections were held:
- The assembly can reopen nominations by majority vote
- This is a debatable motion requiring a majority vote
- The chair would state: "A motion has been made to reopen nominations for the board member position..."
Important Caveats
- Check your bylaws carefully for any nomination procedures (nominating committees, advance deadlines, etc.) that might affect this
- If your bylaws require nominations to be submitted in advance, that could complicate matters and may require a ruling from your parliamentarian or legal counsel
- What your bylaws DO say about the nomination and election process governs over Robert's Rules' default rules
Bottom Line
The member should simply be nominated for their board seat when that election comes up — either through still-open nominations or by the assembly voting to reopen nominations. No special separate election meeting is required.