Can a failed candidate for one office run for another office in the same election
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
If a board member is nominated for vice president and is not elected, does the organization need to hold a separate election for that member to get on the ballot for their original board seat, which is also up for election this year?
Election of Nominees Who Are Unsuccessful
This is an excellent procedural question, and the answer depends entirely on your organization's bylaws and any applicable special rules of order.
The Core Issue
Robert's Rules does not specifically address this scenario by default — it is governed by how your bylaws define the terms and election process for board positions.
Key Questions to Examine in Your Bylaws
-
Did the board member's current term expire? If their board seat's term has not yet ended, there may be nothing to elect — they simply remain in that position.
-
Is the board seat separately on the ballot this year? If the bylaws require that specific seat to be filled by election this cycle, then yes, nominations for that position would need to occur through your normal process.
-
Does your bylaws address "failed candidates"? Some bylaws have provisions allowing a candidate who loses one race to be considered for another position in the same election.
General Robert's Rules Guidance
Under Robert's Rules, each office is a separate election. A nomination for one office does not automatically carry over to another office. If the board seat requires an election, the member would generally need to be separately nominated for that position through your normal nominations process.
Practical Recommendation
⚠️ Review your bylaws carefully for:
- Term lengths for board positions
- Whether the specific seat is up for election this year
- Your nominations procedure (committee, floor nominations, or both)
If the bylaws are silent or ambiguous, the assembly has the authority to make a reasonable interpretation, and it would be advisable to allow floor nominations for the board seat so the member has an opportunity to be placed on the ballot.