Can a custom or longstanding practice become a rule of order
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Can a custom be adopted and become a rule of order?
Custom as a Rule of Order
A custom is not itself a rule of order, but an established custom is followed as if a rule required it, so long as it does not conflict with a written rule or the parliamentary authority.
The Standard
Robert's Rules recognizes that an organization may follow a particular practice so consistently that it becomes established custom. Such a custom is treated practically as if a rule prescribed it.
There is no checklist of tests, but a practice qualifies only if it is actually established: followed consistently, over time, as the organization's way of doing things. A practice followed once or twice is not a custom.
How a Custom Stands or Falls
- A custom that does not conflict with any written rule stands. It should be followed unless the assembly, by a majority vote, decides to do otherwise. A single member's objection does not overturn it.
- A custom that conflicts with a written rule falls when a point of order is raised. If a member raises a point of order that the custom conflicts with the bylaws, a special rule of order, or the parliamentary authority, the custom falls and the written rule governs from then on. Such a point of order can be raised at any time.
- To keep a practice that conflicts with the parliamentary authority, the organization must adopt a written rule to that effect, such as a special rule of order.
- A custom cannot override the bylaws or any other written rule.
Practical Takeaway
| Situation | Result |
|---|---|
| Established practice, no conflict with any written rule | Followed as if it were a rule |
| One member objects to a non-conflicting custom | Custom stands; the assembly may depart from it by majority vote |
| Custom conflicts with a written rule, and a point of order is raised | Custom falls; the written rule governs |
| Organization wants to keep a conflicting practice | Adopt a special rule of order or amend the bylaws |
Best Practice
Rather than relying on custom, an organization that wants a practice to be a rule should adopt it in writing. A rule of parliamentary procedure is adopted as a special rule of order, which requires previous notice and a two-thirds vote, or a vote of a majority of the entire membership. An administrative practice can be adopted as a standing rule by majority vote. Either way, the rule is clearly recorded.