Can a committee divide a motion to approve a proposal into separate votes on criteria and description
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
If a written proposal includes both an internal set of criteria addressed on the application and a separate description intended for outward-facing published information, can a committee reviewing these proposals divide the motion to approve into two separate votes — one on whether the proposal meets the internal criteria and one on the language used in the outward-facing description?
Dividing a Motion to Approve a Proposal
The short answer is yes, this is procedurally possible, but with important conditions. Here's a full breakdown:
The Motion: Division of a Question (, Robert's Rules)
The motion to Divide the Question is an incidental motion that allows an assembly or committee to separate a motion into distinct parts for independent consideration and voting.
Requirements for Division of a Question:
- Each part must be able to stand alone as an independent proposition
- Each part must be capable of standing as a complete motion if the other parts are removed
- It requires a second
- It is not debatable (the motion to divide itself)
- It requires a majority vote (or unanimous consent)
Applied to This Scenario
A proposal containing both internal criteria compliance and an outward-facing description includes two functionally distinct components:
| Component | Nature |
|---|---|
| Internal criteria compliance | Evaluative/gatekeeping function |
| Outward-facing description | Editorial/substantive language |
These can logically be separated because:
- The criteria compliance question asks: "Does this proposal qualify?"
- The description question asks: "Is this language appropriate for publication?"
These are genuinely different kinds of judgments, which supports division being appropriate.
Important Caveats
⚠️ The "Stand Alone" Test Is Critical
The key question is whether approval of one part without the other makes sense. Consider:
- Can criteria compliance be approved without approving any catalog description? (Possibly — pending revision of language)
- Can catalog language be approved without the criteria being met? (Probably not — this would be the illogical result)
This asymmetry suggests the committee should consider which part is voted on first — typically the threshold question (criteria compliance) should come first, so that a failed criteria vote could render the description vote moot.
⚠️ Amendment May Be More Practical
Rather than formally dividing the question, the committee might achieve the same result through the motion to Amend, specifically targeting the description language for modification before a final vote on the whole proposal. This is often simpler procedurally.
⚠️ Committee Rules
In committees, procedures are generally more flexible than in full assemblies. The chair of the committee can often facilitate separate discussion of the two components informally, with a formal vote structure determined by the committee.
Recommended Procedure
- When the motion to approve the proposal is pending, a member moves: "I move to divide the question, considering first the internal criteria compliance and separately the description language."
- The motion is seconded
- Voted on (majority required)
- If adopted, the two parts are considered and voted on sequentially, criteria first
Bottom Line
Yes, division is procedurally appropriate provided both parts can stand independently. Given the logical dependency (description arguably shouldn't be approved without criteria being met), voting on criteria compliance first is the most sensible sequence. Alternatively, a motion to amend the description language before final approval may accomplish the same practical goal more simply.