Can a board use Robert's Rules to amend or rescind an inadequate grievance resolution
Asked August 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
If a board-voted grievance resolution did not address or resolve the conduct complained of, can the board use Robert's Rules to amend or rescind that resolution and adopt a new grievance resolution?
Using Robert's Rules to Amend or Rescind a Grievance Resolution
(Note: The relevant section is ** — Rescind, Amend Something Previously Adopted — not, which covers renewal of motions.)
Direct Answer
Yes, generally. A board can use Robert's Rules to rescind or amend a previously adopted grievance resolution, or to adopt a new one, provided the procedural requirements are met — unless the resolution created a contract right or other vested right in an affected party, or unless the organization's bylaws or grievance procedures restrict this.
Procedural Requirements Under Robert's Rules
To rescind or amend a prior resolution, the board needs:
| Notice Given? | Vote Required |
|---|---|
| Previous notice given at prior meeting | Majority vote |
| No previous notice | 2/3 vote, OR majority of the entire board membership |
The motion is:
"I move to rescind [or amend] the resolution adopted at the previous meeting regarding [subject], and to adopt the following resolution in its place:..."
Key Caveats and Considerations
1. Vested or Contract Rights
Robert's Rules explicitly states that a motion to rescind or amend cannot undo action already taken that has given a party a vested right. If the original resolution conferred a benefit already acted upon, rescission may not be fully effective.
2. Pending Appeal or Grievance Process
If the grievance is still actively in process (e.g., under appeal within the organization), the board may be acting on a matter not yet finally resolved. Check whether:
- The grievance procedure has an appeals step that should be used instead
- The bylaws assign grievance authority to the board specifically or to another body
3. Special Rules or Bylaws
Many organizations have grievance procedures in their bylaws or standing rules that may:
- Specify who has authority to resolve grievances
- Establish time limits for action
- Require specific procedures for reconsideration
Local rules always take precedence over Robert's Rules where they conflict.
4. Reconsider vs. Rescind
If the same session is still ongoing, the proper tool may be ** — Reconsider**, not, which applies to revisiting actions from prior sessions. Reconsider requires only a majority vote and must be moved by someone who voted on the prevailing side.
Practical Recommendation
Step 1: Review the organization's bylaws and grievance procedures first — they may govern this situation specifically.
Step 2: Determine whether the matter is from a prior session (use) or the same session (use — Reconsider).
Step 3: If using, provide advance notice where possible to lower the vote threshold to a simple majority.
Step 4: Draft the new resolution carefully to actually address the conduct complained of, so a future challenge is avoided.
Bottom Line
Robert's Rules is an appropriate mechanism for a board to revisit an inadequate grievance resolution, but substantive adequacy (whether the new resolution actually resolves the grievance) is a matter of organizational judgment, not parliamentary procedure. Robert's Rules governs how the board acts, not whether the outcome is substantively fair.