Can a board rescind a grievance resolution and refer it back to committee
Asked August 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Can a board amend or rescind a prior grievance resolution and refer the underlying grievance back to committee for further investigation and a new recommendation?
Rescinding or Amending a Prior Grievance Resolution
Direct Answer
Yes, generally a board can rescind or amend a prior resolution and refer the matter back to committee — provided the proper procedural requirements are met and no rights of third parties have been fully vested or executed. However, there are important limitations and conditions to consider.
The Applicable Motion: Rescind / Amend Something Previously Adopted
Under **Robert's Rules, a deliberative body may:
- Rescind a prior action (nullify it entirely), or
- Amend Something Previously Adopted (modify it)
at any meeting, provided proper notice and voting requirements are satisfied.
Vote Required
| Circumstances | Vote Required |
|---|---|
| With previous notice given at a prior meeting or in the call of the meeting | Majority vote |
| Without previous notice | Two-thirds vote or majority of entire membership |
Practical tip: If the board wants a simpler path, give notice at a prior meeting (or in the meeting agenda/call) that the resolution will be reconsidered — this reduces the threshold to a simple majority.
The Combined Procedure
The board can accomplish this in one motion or as a sequence:
Option 1: Single Compound Motion
"I move to rescind the resolution adopted regarding the grievance, and to refer the matter back to the Grievance Committee for further investigation and a new recommendation."
This combines Rescind with Refer to Committee into one main motion.
Option 2: Sequential Motions
- First, Rescind or Amend the prior resolution
- Then, introduce a new Main Motion to refer the grievance back to committee
Critical Limitations
1. Action Already Executed or Rights Vested
**Robert's Rules expressly states that Rescind/Amend Something Previously Adopted cannot undo action already taken that has been fully executed or that has granted a right to a non-member or outside party that they have relied upon. If the grievance resolution already resulted in:
- A termination carried out
- A penalty fully imposed
- A legally binding agreement
...the board may be legally constrained even if parliamentarily free to act.
2. Bylaws and Special Rules
The organization's bylaws or grievance procedures may:
- Specify finality of grievance decisions
- Require certain vote thresholds
- Limit the ability to re-open settled grievances
- Provide appeal rights rather than reconsideration rights
Local rules always take precedence over Robert's Rules.
3. Due Process and Contractual Obligations
In organizations with employment relationships, union contracts, or membership rights, reopening a grievance decision may implicate legal obligations beyond parliamentary procedure. Consult legal counsel if applicable.
4. Reconsider vs. Rescind
If the same session (or, in a board context, the same or next meeting) is still in play, the motion to Reconsider may be the more appropriate vehicle — it has different timing rules and can only be moved by someone who voted on the prevailing side.
Summary
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Can the board rescind a prior grievance resolution? | Yes, following requirements |
| Can it simultaneously refer back to committee? | Yes, combined into one motion |
| Is notice advisable? | Strongly yes — reduces vote threshold |
| Are there limits? | Yes — executed actions, bylaws, legal rights |