Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Can a board of trustees require a faculty governance committee to sign an NDA

Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


A college has a committee elected by the faculty and charged with bringing business to the faculty. If the board of trustees asks the members of this committee to sign an NDA, does that conflict with the shared governance the committee is supposed to facilitate?

NDAs and Shared Governance: A Parliamentary/Governance Analysis

This is an excellent governance question that touches on parliamentary principles even if it goes slightly beyond pure Robert's Rules procedure. Let me address it substantively.

The Core Conflict

Yes, there is a significant and direct conflict. Here's why:


What Shared Governance Requires

A faculty committee elected to bring business to the faculty has an agency relationship with the faculty. This means:

  • The committee represents the faculty
  • Members have a duty to report back to their constituents
  • The faculty retains deliberative authority — they cannot exercise it without information
  • Transparency is structurally essential to the committee's function

Under sound parliamentary principles (Robert's Rules and related sections on committee duties), a committee charged with reporting to a larger body cannot fulfill that charge if it is legally prohibited from reporting.


Why an NDA Creates a Problem

Shared Governance Requires NDA Potentially Prevents
Reporting back to faculty Disclosing confidential information
Informed faculty deliberation Faculty receiving necessary information
Member accountability to constituents Members explaining their positions/votes
Transparent decision-making Open discussion of board matters

Key Questions to Consider

1. What exactly would the NDA cover?

  • If it covers everything discussed, it effectively nullifies the committee's mandate
  • If it covers only specific sensitive items (personnel, legal matters), that may be more defensible

2. Who authorized this committee?

  • Faculty bylaws or governance documents likely define the committee's duties
  • An NDA that conflicts with those duties may be ultra vires (beyond the board's authority in this context)

3. Can members even sign?

  • Members elected by the faculty arguably cannot unilaterally waive their reporting obligations without faculty consent
  • Signing may place them in an impossible legal/ethical bind

The Parliamentary Principle at Stake

A deliberative body cannot make informed decisions without informed members.

If the faculty committee cannot report what it learned, the faculty is effectively excluded from governance — which is precisely what the committee was designed to prevent.


Recommended Actions

  1. Consult the faculty governance documents/bylaws — the committee's duties are likely defined there
  2. Raise a formal objection through proper channels if the NDA conflicts with the committee's charge
  3. The full faculty should deliberate on whether to authorize members to accept NDA terms — this is arguably their decision, not the committee's alone
  4. Seek legal counsel — this has legal dimensions beyond parliamentary procedure

Bottom Line

Shared governance is fundamentally incompatible with blanket NDAs imposed on the faculty's own representative committee. The committee exists to transmit information and business between governance bodies. Silencing it doesn't regulate shared governance — it eliminates it.

This is a situation where the faculty as a body should formally weigh in, likely through a motion at a faculty meeting addressing whether and under what conditions such an arrangement is acceptable.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions