Can a board limit questions and comments from non-members at meetings
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Can a board limit questions and comments from people who are allowed to attend its meetings but are not board members?
Limiting Participation from Non-Members at Meetings
The answer depends on who is attending and what type of meeting it is.
The Basic Rule
Under Robert's Rules, the right to make motions, debate, and vote belongs exclusively to members of the assembly. Non-members have no parliamentary right to participate unless granted permission.
*Robert's Rules — A deliberative assembly has the right to control who may attend and participate in its meetings.
Two Categories of Attendees to Consider
1. Non-Members Allowed to Attend (Guests/Public)
- Non-members may attend only by permission of the assembly
- They have no right to speak or participate unless the assembly grants it
- The board may set rules on whether guests may ask questions or comment, and for how long
2. Members of the Organization (Not on the Board)
- In many organizations, general members may have a right to attend board meetings
- However, board meetings are for the board — general members still have no automatic right to speak
- The board may permit or limit their participation
How a Board Can Establish Limits
The board may adopt rules such as:
- A public comment period with time limits (e.g., 3 minutes per person)
- Requiring speakers to sign up in advance
- Limiting comments to agenda items only
- Restricting the total time for public comment
These can be established by:
- Standing rules adopted by the board
- A motion adopted at the meeting controlling that session
- Bylaws provisions (if the organization chooses to codify them)
Important Caveats
| Situation | Notes |
|---|---|
| Government bodies | Open meetings laws (sunshine laws) may impose additional requirements — Robert's Rules does not govern these |
| HOAs/Nonprofits | State law may grant members specific rights to speak at meetings |
| Bylaws | Local rules always take precedence over Robert's Rules |
Bottom Line
Yes, a board may limit or structure participation from attendees who are not board members. The most orderly approach is to adopt clear standing rules establishing a public comment procedure so expectations are set in advance.