Can a board deny floor nominations at a nonprofit AGM
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Can a sitting board of a nonprofit society deny nominations from the floor at an AGM?
Nominations from the Floor at a Nonprofit Society AGM
Short Answer
Generally, no — a sitting board cannot unilaterally deny nominations from the floor at an AGM, unless there is specific authority to do so in the society's governing documents.
The General Rule
Under Robert's Rules, nominations from the floor are a fundamental membership right. Once nominations are open, any member in good standing may nominate a qualified candidate. A board does not have authority to block this unless:
- The bylaws explicitly restrict or eliminate floor nominations
- The constitution/bylaws establish a closed nomination process
What the Board CAN Legitimately Do
| Permissible | Not Permissible |
|---|---|
| Require nominees to be members in good standing | Arbitrarily reject qualified nominees |
| Apply eligibility criteria already in the bylaws | Invent new eligibility rules at the meeting |
| Set a pre-meeting nomination deadline (if in bylaws) | Close nominations before members have opportunity to nominate |
| Require written consent of nominee | Refuse nominations without bylaw authority |
What Members Can Do If Nominations Are Improperly Denied
- Raise a Point of Order — challenge the chair's ruling immediately
- Appeal the ruling — requires a second, is debatable, and a majority vote overrules the chair
- Post-meeting — file a complaint under your jurisdiction's applicable nonprofit legislation or seek judicial relief
Practical Recommendation
Review your society's constitution and bylaws carefully. If they are silent on nominations, floor nominations must be permitted. If the board is attempting to deny them without bylaw authority, that action is likely invalid and challengeable.
Consider consulting a lawyer familiar with nonprofit law in your jurisdiction if the board persists in denying legitimate nominations.