Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Can a board ballot requiring unanimity be sent by BCC email

Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


If I need to circulate a ballot to a board of directors that requires a unanimous decision, should it be sent BCC?

The question of whether to send the ballot BCC is a practical email/technology question, not strictly a parliamentary one — but the parliamentary rules around unanimous decisions and ballot secrecy are relevant here.

Key Considerations

First: Does your situation actually require a ballot?

If a decision requires unanimity, a ballot vote is somewhat unusual. A ballot is designed for secret voting, but unanimity means every single member must vote in favor — so the result is essentially public by definition. If even one member votes no, the measure fails, and you'd need to know who to follow up with.

For a unanimous decision, unanimous consent is often more appropriate: you circulate the proposal and ask members to signal agreement or objection. Any objection defeats it immediately.

Second: If a ballot is required by your bylaws or rules:

  • The ballot should be sent individually to each board member
  • Responses should be collected by the secretary or a designated teller, not shared among the group
  • BCC protects members from seeing each other's responses only if members are replying to the sender — it doesn't by itself create a proper secret ballot process

Third: Circular/mail ballots require authorization

Voting outside of a meeting — by email or mailed ballot — is not permitted under Robert's Rules unless your bylaws specifically authorize it. Many board bylaws do include such authorization, but you should verify yours do before proceeding.

Practical Recommendation

If your bylaws authorize electronic or mail ballots, the cleaner approach is a web-based voting portal or individual emails where each member responds privately to the secretary, who tallies and reports results. BCC on a group email is a workaround that may not meet the standard of a proper ballot process.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions