Are rhetorical questions allowed during debate under Robert's Rules
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
If a motion includes a quoted cost and a member asks, "This is a lot of money, isn't this expensive?" — is this an appropriate way to participate in debate?
Debate vs. Questions in Parliamentary Procedure
The Short Answer
What you've described — "This is a lot of money, isn't this expensive?" — is not really a question at all. It is a debating point or opinion expressed as a rhetorical question, and it is entirely appropriate in debate.
Key Distinctions
Rhetorical Questions (Appropriate in Debate)
A member saying "Isn't this expensive?" is expressing their opinion or concern about the motion in question form. This is perfectly acceptable because:
- It conveys the member's position on the merits
- It is germane to the motion being considered
- It is directed to the assembly, not a request for factual information from the chair
Robert's Rules recognizes that members use debate to express views, ask rhetorical questions, and persuade others
Genuine Parliamentary Questions (Different Process)
If a member has an actual question requiring factual information, there are proper mechanisms:
- Parliamentary Inquiry — directed to the chair about procedure
- Point of Information — a request for factual information, directed through the chair
Practical Guidance for the Chair
The chair should:
- ✅ Allow it — treat it as a debating statement
- Not require an answer from anyone unless the member is genuinely seeking information
- Remind members that debate time is being used if relevant
Bottom Line
Debate is broad. Members may argue, persuade, and yes — ask rhetorical questions. The statement "Isn't this expensive?" is simply a member expressing opposition or concern during debate, which is exactly what debate is for.