Are abstain votes formally offered during a motion under Robert's Rules
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Is it standard procedure to offer the options of yay, nay, and abstain when voting on a motion?
Voting Options Under Robert's Rules
The standard options are "Aye," "No," and the right to abstain — but abstention is not formally offered as an option by the chair.
How the Chair Properly Puts a Motion to a Vote
Under Robert's Rules, the chair calls for the vote this way:
"Those in favor, say 'Aye'... Those opposed, say 'No'..."
The chair then does not say "abstentions?" — abstention is simply the act of remaining silent during both calls.
Key Points on Abstention
- Members always have the right to abstain — no one can be compelled to vote
- Abstentions are not counted as votes in either direction
- Abstentions do not affect the outcome — the question is decided by those who do vote
- The chair does not formally call for abstentions in standard procedure
- Saying "present" instead of aye/no is common in legislative bodies but not standard Robert's Rules practice
A Note on Terminology
- The correct term is "Aye" (not "Yay") for the affirmative
- The correct term is "No" (not "Nay") — though "nay" is common in legislative bodies like Congress
When Abstentions Are Recorded
Abstentions may be recorded in a roll call vote if members explicitly state they are abstaining.
Bottom line: Standard procedure is Aye/No, with abstention being a silent, always-available option — not a formally called third choice.