Options when a director does not support the nonprofit as required by bylaws
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
What options are available if a director does not support the nonprofit corporation, as required by the bylaws?
Your question touches on both parliamentary procedure and nonprofit governance. Here's how the procedural side works:
Addressing a Director Who Fails to Fulfill Duties
If the bylaws contain provisions regarding director support or participation requirements, the board or membership has several procedural options:
1. Censure
The board or assembly can pass a motion to formally censure the director — a statement of official disapproval. This requires a main motion, debate, and a majority vote. It carries no removal from office but is a formal rebuke on the record.
2. Request to Resign
The board may pass a motion requesting the director's resignation. This is not binding, but it creates a formal record of the board's position.
3. Removal from Office
If the bylaws authorize it — and many nonprofit bylaws do — the board or membership can remove a director by motion. Under Robert's Rules, an officer or director who was elected by the membership can generally only be removed by the membership, not by the board alone, unless the bylaws specifically grant the board that authority.
Removal typically requires:
- Advance notice to the director
- An opportunity for the director to be heard
- A two-thirds vote, or a majority of the entire membership, depending on what the bylaws specify
4. Bylaw-Based Automatic Removal
If the bylaws specify that failure to meet certain requirements (attendance, financial support, etc.) constitutes automatic grounds for removal or creates a vacancy, the chair may simply declare the seat vacant after the triggering condition is documented.
Important Caveats
- Your bylaws control. The specific language in your bylaws regarding director duties and removal procedures takes precedence. Review those provisions carefully before proceeding.
- State law matters. Nonprofit corporation laws vary by state and may impose additional requirements or protections for directors.
- Due process. Even when removal is procedurally valid, giving the director notice and a chance to respond protects the organization and strengthens the legitimacy of any action taken.