Can the chair forbid debate after taking a motion from the table
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Our board tabled a discussion to gather more research on the topic before voting. At the next meeting, the chair explained that we now needed a motion to take it off the table and vote, with no further discussion of the tabled issue. I have no problem with taking it off the table — my problem is the chair demanding there be no further discussion before the vote.
The Chair's Ruling Is Incorrect
You are right to question this. The chair's demand is a procedural error. Here's why:
What "Take from the Table" Actually Does
When a motion is taken from the table (formally: the Motion to Take from the Table, RONR §34), it resumes consideration of the motion in exactly the same state it was in when tabled — but that does not mean debate is closed.
Taking a motion from the table restores full debate rights unless debate has been separately closed by another motion (such as the Previous Question).
The Chair Would Need a Separate Motion to Close Debate
If the chair wants to prevent discussion before the vote, the only proper way to do that is:
- Take the motion from the table (majority vote)
- Then a member moves the Previous Question (§16)
- That motion requires a second and a two-thirds vote to pass
- Only then is debate closed and the vote taken immediately
The chair cannot unilaterally impose this — it requires the assembly's consent by a two-thirds vote.
How to Respond
You have two good options:
- Rise to a Point of Order (§23) — State: "Point of Order. The chair does not have the authority to prevent debate on a motion that has been taken from the table without a vote of the assembly."
- Appeal the Chair's Decision (§24) — If the chair rules against your Point of Order, you can appeal: "I appeal the decision of the chair." This requires a second and a majority vote to overturn.
Key Takeaway
The chair facilitates procedure — they do not dictate whether debate occurs. Only the assembly itself can close debate, and only by a two-thirds vote (RONR §§16, 43).