Can a point of order be raised late for a continuing breach
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Can a point of order be raised late if the violation is a continuing breach?
Point of Order for a Continuing Breach
The General Rule on Timeliness
Normally, a point of order must be raised promptly — as soon as the violation occurs. If a member allows the moment to pass without objection, the right to raise that point is typically lost.
The Exception: Continuing Breach
A continuing breach is an ongoing violation — one that persists from moment to moment rather than occurring as a single past event. Because the violation is still happening, the right to raise a point of order is not lost by delay. A member may raise the point at any time while the breach continues.
Common Examples of Continuing Breaches
- A motion that was adopted but is beyond the assembly's authority (e.g., violates the bylaws or the organization's governing documents)
- A main motion that contains something fundamentally improper in its substance
- A situation where the assembly is proceeding without a quorum and business is being transacted
How to Raise It
The procedure is the same as any point of order:
- Member: "Point of order!"
- Chair: "State your point of order."
- Member: States the nature of the continuing violation.
- Chair: Rules the point well taken or not well taken.
If You Disagree with the Chair's Ruling
A member who believes the chair ruled incorrectly may appeal the decision. An appeal requires a second, allows limited debate, and is decided by a majority vote — a tie vote sustains the chair's ruling.
Key Takeaway
The continuing breach exception exists because it would be unfair to let a fundamental, ongoing violation stand simply because no one objected immediately. As long as the improper condition persists, the point of order remains available.